By Amy Amatangelo, TV Gal ®
When I first started writing about TV, I could list my ten best shows of the year with confidence. Sure one viewer’s trash is another’s treasure (some think American Horror Story is brilliant, I find it rather laughable). Lists are always subjective and my opinion is just my opinion. But, back then, I had at least watched one episode of every show and felt I had given every series its fair consideration.
That, my friends, is no longer the case. Even if I did nothing else but watch TV, I don’t think I would be able to say I’ve seen everything the medium has to offer. There are way too many shows on the air. For example, I will admit to you that I’ve never seen a single episode of Justified. It’s been on my “I need to watch this show” list for years. There are other shows I liked –The Walking Dead and Breaking Bad among them – that for whatever reason I haven’t kept up with. The second season of Downton Abbey is just sitting on my desk waiting to be watched. Do spa/TV viewing vacations exist? Because that’s what I need.
My other issue is the rise of what I like to calls shows that are rated NFA – Not For Amy. For example, I can appreciate that Lena Dunham is creating something unique with a distinct point of view with Girls. However, from the opening moments, I couldn’t stand the show. I found the characters to be whiny, obnoxious and self-centered. And series such as Game of Thrones are also NFA. With its gratuitous sex and violence, I didn’t even make it through the series premiere of Game of Thrones.
What I can offer you are my favorite shows of the year. The shows that have been consistently high in quality. Show that each week offered thoughtful, moving performances and strong writing. Shows that make me laugh, cry or both. Shows that are among the best TV has to offer. I have ranked them in terms of what I would choose to watch first on my TiVo.
1.Homeland (Showtime): So we’re all kind of in a fight with Homeland and I totally get that. The show is cutting corners and sacrificing realism to advance the story and get the characters where they need them to be. I mean we’re going to have to ask Carrie more follow-up questions about how she escaped from Abu Nazir, right? An acceptable answer isn’t “I got lucky” when it comes to freeing yourself from the world’s number one terrorist. But all my quibbles aside, no other show surprises me and keeps me engaged like Homeland does. Especially in season two, I never knew what the show was going to do next. Every time I lulled myself into believing I knew what was going to happen, the series zigged in a totally different direction. But what really sets Homeland apart is the incredible acting. Clare Danes, Damian Lewis and Mandy Patinkin are breathtaking every week. They rise above the most inane writing and ridiculous plot twists. Danes and Lewis have made me believe in TV’s most unlikely and unhealthy romance. It’s been a long time since I’ve looked forward to a show as much as I look forward to Homeland. And that means, despite the ridiculousness of late, the drama is doing a lot of things right.
2.Parenthood (NBC): This is the season Parenthood transitioned from a good drama into a great one. I wrote about Parenthood being one of the best shows for Paste Magazine. You can read what I had to say here.
3. Southland (TNT): The best cop drama on TV. With gritty realism, Southland pulls the viewer into its world each week. This past season the drama added Lucy Liu and, as much as I enjoy Liu on Elementary, I am really going to miss her on Southland. Her performance was transformative. I could write paragraphs about the brilliant acting that occurs each week on the show but I want to especially praise Regina King, whose Detective Lydia Adams is one of the strongest female characters on TV. Bonus points to the show for having C. Thomas Howell in its cast. When I was a girl, pictures of Howell adorned my bedroom walls. How wonderful it is to have him on TV. Some things that are gold can stay.
4. The Middle (ABC): This week Frankie (Patricia Heaton) woke up in the middle of the night to fight with Mike (Neil Flynn) and you know what I loved best about that scene? Frankie was in mismatched pajamas. That, my friends, is real life. (My biggest complaint with Homeland this season remains that Jess packed a negligee to go to a safe house). While Modern Family may be the show all the cool kids watch, The Middle is the show that truly captures the humor of family life. The comedy has the best teenage characters of any show. Each week Eden Sher and Charlie McDermott are perfect as the ever enthusiastic Sue and her older, slacker brother Axl. (For real fun, follow these two on Twitter to see how they interact in real life). When people ask me what’s the one show they are not watching that that they should be watching, I always say The Middle.
5. Scandal (ABC): From her first power-suit strut into the office, I was all about Olivia Pope and her not-so-merry band of Gladiators. The show provides a juicy soap opera and intense mystery while, without making a big deal about it, has built a show around a successful woman of color. Plus nobody enunciates quite like Kerry Washington enunciates. I want to be a client of Pope & Associates just so I can hear Olivia say my name. Most of the time, I have no idea what the Huck the show is going to do next and I love that.
6. Parks and Recreation (NBC): What other series could make local politics so utterly compelling? I literally love this show. Parks has the best ensemble cast on TV. There are no weak links. I adore every single character on it.
7. The Glee Project (Oxygen): The Glee Project is the only reality competition that is truly rooted in reality. The audition process is grueling and, in the end, no matter how much the casting director, vocal coach and choreographer may love you, it all comes down to the executive producer’s capricious decision. I love that this is a tough competition but one where none of the coaches are mean-spirited or nasty. If you’re not performing well, they will tell you but in a way that allows the performers to flourish. Bonus points to the show for 1): Totally making up words. We all need a little glee-ality and romanticality in our lives. 2): Giving me my new secret boyfriend Zach Woodlee. His proud papa face when he watches the kids perform makes me tear up every time. 3): Giving Glee Blake Jenner and Alex Newell. They’ve both been great additions to the series.
8. Mad Men (AMC): Not everything worked this season but when the show worked, it worked brilliantly. Joan finally telling her husband to get out. Peggy leaving the agency and coming into her own. Joan becoming a partner in the worst possible way. These are TV moments indelibly inked in my mind. Mad Men continues to create a world that is mesmerizing.
9. Awkward (MTV): Yes I know I’m way too old to be watching this show. But what I love about Awkward is that although the technology has changed (no one had a blog when I was in high school), the experience of being a teenager hasn’t. Awkward takes me right back to the not-so-glory days of high school. But it’s not just nostalgia that makes me love the show – it is witty, hilarious, poignant and heart-breaking. While I always rooted for Jake, the Jake/Matty/Jenna love triangle is one of the best ones out there.
10. New Girl (FOX): For a show ostensibly about a girl, it’s the men who have made this comedy flourish. The rapport between Schmidt, Nick and Winston is the stuff of TV magic. If Schmidt is the series breakout character, Nick is the sleeper breakout character. I still laugh every time I think about Jake Johnson’s “I give you cookie” diatribe.
The Good Wife (CBS): I adore this show. The only reason it isn’t part of my top ten is due to the mandatory “Nick is a bad husband” deduction. May we never have to see a fight involving raw eggs again.
30 Rock (NBC): As always, I want to go to there. In its final season, this smart comedy has enjoyed a greater and more hilarious freedom as it mocks its corporate parent and takes Liz Lemon through some major life changes.
Switched at Birth (ABC): Bunheads may be Gilmore Girls Redux but it’s Switched at Birth that has filled the hole Gilmore Girls left in my viewing schedule.
Go On (NBC): This comedy is doing exactly what a freshman comedy should be doing: It gets better every week as Ryan (Matthew Perry) continues to grieve his wife’s death with an unlikely support group. It can’t be easy to make a comedy about people continuing on with their lives after a great loss, but Go On is doing an excellent job.
Those are my favorite shows of 2012. What are yours? Talk about it below.
Go On has been such a pleasant surprise. I didn’t think it could possibly work, but it does, and I’m beginning to care about the characters. I especially like what they are doing with Julie White’s character. I hope that they will continue to give some of the other more quirky characters more dimension as the season progresses.
P.S. Hy husband and I both love Awkward!
I adore Julie White’s character. I will be talking more about her soon!
For someone who has three TIVOs, picking a top 10 is really hard…it depends on my mood, the time of day or the season. But if you had to pin me down today, the best shows on TV, the ones I watch even when I know that should watch ones that were recorded a couple weeks ago, would be…Parks and Recreations, Go On, Person of Interest, Parenthood (just so I can cry once a week over something that is not my own), Ben and Kate, Once Upon A Time, New Girl (the Christmas party episode was awesome), Bones (I will never leave this show), Necessary Roughness (it’s time everyone sees Scott Cohen as a sex symbol) and Scandal. I wonder if this was a personality question, what my list says about me!!!???
I love Parenthood but hate the Ray Romano storyline which takes it out of my top 10. My top shows are Once Upon A Time (this show just makes me happy, I love everything about it) Sons of Anarchy, The Walking Dead, Homeland, Scandal, The Big Bang Theory, Pretty Little Liars, Game of Thrones, Southland, and Justified..
I don’t know if I can name ten must-see shows, but I’ll try: How I met your mother, New girl, Suburgatory, Modern Family, Downton Abbey. I must say I feel a little disappointed on TV right now, I watch other shows but I still have not found my Gilmore Girls replacement nor Everwood, my all time favorites. I started watching Parenthood and liked it but I have not catched up yet with the current season. Loved the first two seasons of Mad Men but it became too sad and dark to continue watching.
I can’t put it in order because it seems to change all the time, but I’ll list my top 10 for this year. 🙂
2. Covert Affairs
3. New Girl
4. Happy Endings
5. Hart of Dixie (I just love this show so much. So glad it made it to season 2.)
6. Grimm (if nothing more than I feel it’s improved greatly since season 1)
7. Rookie Blue
9. Burn Notice
10. The Closer (I thought it had an excellent ending run of the series, but I just can’t get into Major Crimes for some reason and it makes me sad.) 😦
Chuck- I love and miss the show so I will always mention it honorably. Plus, even just 3 or 4 weeks counts for 2012.
Psych-Great season 6, I hate how they are treating it now and how long we’ve waited, but I can’t wait for Season 7 in February.
I’m still working on my top 10 list, but I can say that for sure it will include Breaking Bad, The Walking Dead, Dexter, Bob’s Burgers, Happy Endings, Parenthood and Missing (yes, I might be the only person who loved that show!).
Ones that may or may not take those final 3 spots are The Middle, The Neighbors, The League, Jane By Design, Bunk, Misfits (UK show on Hulu in US), Spy (UK show on Hulu in US), Elementary
and American Horror Story.
I haven’t seen a couple of these shows, but I absolutely love Scandal. I got into it after a friend I work with at DISH recommended it, and now I’m hooked. I watch it every week on my DISH Hopper, which is set to auto-record it along with the other big four primetime network shows using PrimeTime Anytime, so I never have to worry about missing an episode even if I forget to set a timer. It’s an amazing show, with a great lead actress and enough drama and unexpected twists that it keeps me on the edge of my seat.
I’m surprised there’s no mention of Newsroom. That, Scandal, Walking Dead, and Pretty Little Liars are all high up on my list.